|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Questions and answers:Q. "I built a prototype using two strips of sheet metal screwed down to a piece of wood for the switch or key to switch the electricity on or off." "I used a nail as the core of my electromagnet and I wound 100 turns of insulated wire around the nail. I mounted the nail so that it would attract a piece of springy iron when it was activated. (at first, I used a piece of aluminum or copper metal and discovered that the metal had to be iron or ferrous metal for the magnet to be able to pull on it)." "I connected them all as in your diagram and used a battery holder and two "D" size flashlight batteries to provide the voltage." "When I push the key, it brings the two pieces of metal together and completes the electrical circuit. The electromagnet then pulls in the piece of springy iron and it makes a nice click." "I can't figure out how to differentiate between a dot and a dash when all I get is a click". (All he needs to do is to put a second piece of metal up OVER the piece of springy sheet metal of the sounder to make a second click. when the sounder releases, and he will have made a complete replica telegraph system. - - see detailed explanation below - -) "I built another prototype hooking a buzzer to the circuit instead of the sounder. That took care of the problem of telling the difference between a dot and a dash, but it isn't much of a challenge or learning experience for the kids." "Any help or suggestions would be appreciated." --------------------------------------------------------------------- A. What a great project! Congratulations on creating a working system like that... Yes, It is easier to have the kids learn to use a buzzer than to use a clicking "sounder". A doorbell buzzer, available in hardware stores approximates the early buzzer sounds quite well. The sounders used from 1850-1950 were like your nail/solenoid.... IF... you were to modify it by putting a piece of metal OVER the piece of sheet metal that is moved by the electromagnet. This would give you a system that made a click when the electromagnet pulled IN and a slightly different clack when the electromagnet released. Sounders all make a slightly different
sound when they pull-in rather than release and the operator learns to
discriminate between these two different sounds and soon unconsciously can
tell a dot from a dash. That might be a bit of a challenge to learn so you might want to go to the buzzer system used from about 1910 to 1950. You could also try using very different metal parts to strike on the pull-in and release to make the sound difference even more noticeable. You could also use a light bulb as an adjunct to the sounder and have it go on whenever the sounder was activated. This might help the kids learn to copy the code. You could also mount a pencil on the sounder arm and have it mark a piece of paper with either a high mark or a low mark while the paper was pulled under the pencil at an approximately constant speed. This would approximate Samual Morse's very first telegraph systems used before people learned to copy code by ear. Morse invented a "register" which used a clockwork mechanism to pull a paper tape under a pencil which was moved in and out by an electromagnet. If you used this system, you could translate the short downwards pencil marks on the paper as dots... and the long downwards pencil marks on the paper as dashes... Good luck with your project. PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONSOverheating and dead batteries One parent emailed that all his completed set did was to have the coil of wire get very hot and that the battery went dead shortly afterwards. After asking him a few questions, I found out that he had wound bare (uninsulated) wire around the nail. I explained that the coil of wire had to be made from insulated wire so that the individual turns in the coil did not electrically connect to each other. Sticking Sounder: One parent noted that closing the key caused the electromagnet to attract the metal armature of the sounder but that it did not release after the circuit was opened. I suggested increasing the strength of
the springiness of the metal that pulled the armature away from the
nail... PLEASE let me know if you have problems or solutions that might be of interest to other builders... Good Luck with your project... and don't forget to send pictures... |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||